Drained brain
January 19th, 2006 by isacutie20 January 2006, 9:18a
Was reading the online papers and came across a depressing article in the Manila Times. The title is "GMA urges more supply of RP nurses". Here’s an excerpt:
The country’s "brain drain," caused by the strong employment abroad of nurses and doctors, is compensated by their considerable dollar remittances to the country," President Arroyo said during her Wednesday interaction with the media at the municipal hall here.
"The drain I would say is more than compensated by the fact that the Filipinos who went abroad keep sending remittances home. With their remittances, the education capacity of their families is enhanced," she said. (I’ve got this in red because I was seeing red as I read the article.)
Duh!
Omigosh…is this woman even thinking before speaking? Ok, I know she has a tendency not to (which explains why she is frequently "na-ku-kuryente"), but it makes me wonder if she understood what she was saying? No wonder this country is spiralling downwards. So, in effect, what she’s saying is it’s okay for us to send our best minds, best carers abroad, so long as they keep sending their money back home. Okay, sure they do send money, but hasn’t she realized that in most cases, those who leave eventually send for their family (to whom they send their hard-earned money) to join them? What then? Who will they send the money to? Those dollar remittances will eventually dwindle.
And even if they do keep sending heaps and heaps of dollars to the country, what about the rest of the people who are here. Unfortunately, despite the economic recovery pronouncements of the government, your average Juan and Juana de la Cruz aren’t heaping the benefits. And I don’t think remittances will solve the country’s problems (graft and corruption is up there on top). Such a short-sighted view from a woman who is supposed to be a brilliant economist. I’m sure I’m not the only one thinking that life in the Philippinnes certainly isn’t as good as it used to be (even compared to just a few years ago).
And what’s this with "the education capacity of their families is enhanced"? Doesn’t she know that it is not only nurses and doctors that are in exodus, but teachers too (and even those in other lines of work, except for movie stars and politicians)? The very people who are supposed to be educating our youths are packing up and going. Has she not noticed that the quality of education in the country is shot? Even the teachers at expensive, quality, private schools are taking jobs abroad! Good education gets more expensive each year, and yet the people teaching are becoming less and less competent. Oh sure, I know there are still great teachers out there, but they are declining in number.
But really, to read that the country’s president is actually advocating the we train more nurses and doctors (and perhaps she also was thinking of teachers) so they can leave and then send dollars back home is sickening. So, who’s going to take care of the sick here at home? Who’s going to teach the ones left here at home? Has she thought about that?
GMA is supposed to be a brain, but I’m beginning to think that her brain has really been drained, and drained to the last drop.
That brings me to another, somewhat related article I read this morning, this time in Manila Standard Today. It’s by Maya Baltazar Herrera and titled "Kites". In it she told of friends who are leaving the country for good, then goes on to discuss the reasons why some people leave the Philippines and some stay. Some people leave because they want to, some leave because they have to. These days, I think more people are leaving because they feel they have to. Even the two examples she cited for wanting to leave reflects the lack of opportunity here in the Philippines (brother who left to get an IT job and friend in medical research).
I cannot count in my hands the number of friends and relatives that have left the Philippines to seek better opportunities abroad, and found them. And more will follow, I’m sure. Even now, a number of them are in the process of migrating. My brother and his family has left the country, and while the reason is not simply economics (although it is a big part), I can’t blame them. I miss them terribly, but I know they’ve got better chances there for a better life. My nephews, one of whom is autistic, stand to have better education where they are now and they’re getting better social services. Yeah, homesickeness is the only downside, but thanks to the internet, we are able to keep in close touch. Take homesickness away, and I think they’re doing great.
I can’t blame the people who have upped and left the country. I’ve considered it myself every now and then (I’m actually in the "now" period at the moment). After all, I really don’t see anything good to look forward to in the future here in the Philippines. As a single mother, I keep thinking that if I’m to give my son a good life, I may need to look offshore. Somehow though, something is holding me back. Part of it is I don’t want to leave my father behind, but I know there are other reasons. Ms Herrera says it well for me. She says that she has given easy answers whenever asked about why she stays in the country:
"’As long as I am in the Philippines, I contribute at some level to the nation and its people. If I leave, then I don’t.’ ‘I like being near friends and family.’ ‘I don’t think I would survive in the rat race.’ ‘I really like having maids’. The reality is that many people who reside outside the country continue to send money back. The reality is that my friends and family are in such places as Sydney and Vancouver and Hamburg and Springfield and Los Angeles and Singapore and Hong Kong. The reality is that Manila has its own rat race and there are places even in North America that are more laid back in the Philippines…The reality, I suppose, is that I just like life better here."
That is true for me. My complaints notwithstanding, I generally like my life here, and I’m sure many others who have left to work abroad did too (It’s hard to imagine why anyone in his/her right mind would leave home, family, and friends to try their luck in a strange and what possibly could be a hostile environment unless they feel they need to). Unfortunately, sometimes, you have to sacrifice what you like for more long-term benefits. With the way things are going, I tend to think more and more about the possibility of leaving. It makes me wonder how long I can convince myself that my life is here and not elsewhere.